15 Mar

User talk:Rodhullandemu

‎Streets in Liverpool: err
← Older revision
Revision as of 16:03, 15 March 2013
Line 142:
Line 142:

Re your note on my page. I am trying to tidy up the pages. Perhaps the "Streets in Liverpool" page is one that needs a discussion. To me it seems very random and full of images of unimportant streets. There are thousands of streets in Liverpool! Just regards other things i am tidying up the images. Too many with the wrong categories probably done by bots. [[User:Babydoll0409|Babydoll0409]] ([[User talk:Babydoll0409|talk]]) 15:50, 15 March 2013 (UTC)

Re your note on my page. I am trying to tidy up the pages. Perhaps the "Streets in Liverpool" page is one that needs a discussion. To me it seems very random and full of images of unimportant streets. There are thousands of streets in Liverpool! Just regards other things i am tidying up the images. Too many with the wrong categories probably done by bots. [[User:Babydoll0409|Babydoll0409]] ([[User talk:Babydoll0409|talk]]) 15:50, 15 March 2013 (UTC)
−
:Ideally, the category "Streets in Liverpool" will eventually split into "Streets in Liverpool City Centre" (which we already have) and suburbs, such as "Street in Aigburth" and "Streets in Toxteth" etc. Whether a street is "important" is subjective, and whether it has a category of its own should depend on how many images there are of it here, not its perceived importance. You have to consider what will happen in ten, twenty or a hundred years time- there may be many more images of a particular street over its lifetime. For the moment, I think individual images should be placed into their own category (if more than one image) and the suburb, e.g. images of Granby Street into Category:Granby Street and Category:Streets in Liverpool until we have a Category:Streets in Toxteth. And the date categories should be there for historical perspective which we are as yet unable to see. If you see it differently, please start a discussion. Cheers. [[User:Rodhullandemu|Rodhullandemu]] ([[User talk:Rodhullandemu#top|talk]]) 15:58, 15 March 2013 (UTC)
+
:Ideally, the category "Streets in Liverpool" will eventually split into "Streets in Liverpool City Centre" (which we already have) and suburbs, such as "Street in Aigburth" and "Streets in Toxteth" etc. Whether a street is "important" is subjective, and whether it has a category of its own should depend on how many images there are of it here, not its perceived importance. You have to consider what will happen in ten, twenty or a hundred years time- there may be many more images of a particular street over its lifetime. For the moment, I think individual images should be placed into their own category (if more than one image) and the suburb, e.g. images of Granby Street into Category:Toxteth and Category:Streets in Liverpool until we have a Category:Streets in Toxteth. And the date categories should be there for historical perspective which we are as yet unable to see. If you see it differently, please start a discussion. Cheers. [[User:Rodhullandemu|Rodhullandemu]] ([[User talk:Rodhullandemu#top|talk]]) 15:58, 15 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Rodhullandemu&diff=92627776&oldid=92627743