02 Apr

User talk:Mehdi

‎Boletus pseudosulphureus 165304.jpg: re
← Older revision
Revision as of 08:08, 2 April 2013
Line 74:
Line 74:

Hi. Can I ask, why did you removed the template? Current filename is wrong (misleading) and there's no consensus regarding complete identification of the specie. The most accurate and correct identification available is Boletus of Luridi section. Reason #3 doesn't require binomial filename. --[[User:Xth-Floor|Xth-Floor]] ([[User talk:Xth-Floor|talk]]) 19:37, 1 April 2013 (UTC)

Hi. Can I ask, why did you removed the template? Current filename is wrong (misleading) and there's no consensus regarding complete identification of the specie. The most accurate and correct identification available is Boletus of Luridi section. Reason #3 doesn't require binomial filename. --[[User:Xth-Floor|Xth-Floor]] ([[User talk:Xth-Floor|talk]]) 19:37, 1 April 2013 (UTC)

:Hi. This image used to many articles in Wikipedias! for example [[:en:Boletus pseudosulphureus]]! Your reason is wrong and reason 3 is not usable for this image. plz be attention: You think this name is wrong and it's not a "Boletus pseudosulphureus" but you are not sure about correct name of this file, So you used "Unknown Boletus of Luridi section" name! you have 2 ways for renaming this file: 1- Find a correct name of this Boletus and suggest it! 2-Ask a question in [[User talk:Biopics|user Biopics talk page]] and find a best name for this image.--[[user:Mehdi|Mehdi]]^{[[user_talk:Mehdi|Talk]]} 05:50, 2 April 2013 (UTC)

:Hi. This image used to many articles in Wikipedias! for example [[:en:Boletus pseudosulphureus]]! Your reason is wrong and reason 3 is not usable for this image. plz be attention: You think this name is wrong and it's not a "Boletus pseudosulphureus" but you are not sure about correct name of this file, So you used "Unknown Boletus of Luridi section" name! you have 2 ways for renaming this file: 1- Find a correct name of this Boletus and suggest it! 2-Ask a question in [[User talk:Biopics|user Biopics talk page]] and find a best name for this image.--[[user:Mehdi|Mehdi]]^{[[user_talk:Mehdi|Talk]]} 05:50, 2 April 2013 (UTC)

+
::Hi. 1. The name is wrong, but it's not (just) my thought. 2. It's not possible to identify this specie just by the image, even by professional mycologists. This image is taken from Mushroom Observer (as linked in description). According to professional and amateur mycologists in the discussion, the mushroom cannot be Boletus pseudosulphureus and exact specie cannot be identified just from the image (without molecular analysis). Current filename is definitely wrong and because of that, Wikipedia articles using this image are really misleading. I believe that a more general filename should be preferred to wrong filename. --[[User:Xth-Floor|Xth-Floor]] ([[User talk:Xth-Floor|talk]]) 08:08, 2 April 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Mehdi&diff=93818661&oldid=93814988