17 Mar

User talk:Geagea

‎Help about 'renaming': +
← Older revision
Revision as of 22:04, 17 March 2013
Line 538:
Line 538:

:::We cannot use our own historical moment for naming images. That would be the same that i upload tons of images of Istanbul, and name all of those Constantinople. What, that is the same, right? :) Same here, this image was taken in 2010, so there are no even one reason for it to be named mosque, except POV pushing. Also, i find it very disruptive that Photo Balkan go FORUM SHOPPING with false accusations, except to try to gain consensus on one place, with all involved editors. --[[User:WhiteWriter |WhiteWriter ]]^{[[User talk:WhiteWriter |speaks]]} 13:44, 17 March 2013 (UTC)

:::We cannot use our own historical moment for naming images. That would be the same that i upload tons of images of Istanbul, and name all of those Constantinople. What, that is the same, right? :) Same here, this image was taken in 2010, so there are no even one reason for it to be named mosque, except POV pushing. Also, i find it very disruptive that Photo Balkan go FORUM SHOPPING with false accusations, except to try to gain consensus on one place, with all involved editors. --[[User:WhiteWriter |WhiteWriter ]]^{[[User talk:WhiteWriter |speaks]]} 13:44, 17 March 2013 (UTC)

::::WhiteWriter, you have done correctly that you did not renamed the file by yourself even though you have file mover rights but you have to read [[COM:NPOV]]: ''Commons is not Wikipedia, and files uploaded here do not necessarily need to comply with the Neutral point of view and No original research requirements imposed by many of the Wikipedia sites.'' Anyway, the hebrew article says that that building was once also mosque, which means that tha clam "misleading name: is not obvious and you have first pass through discussion in the files talk page. [[User:Geagea|Geagea]] ([[User talk:Geagea#top|talk]]) 17:34, 17 March 2013 (UTC)

::::WhiteWriter, you have done correctly that you did not renamed the file by yourself even though you have file mover rights but you have to read [[COM:NPOV]]: ''Commons is not Wikipedia, and files uploaded here do not necessarily need to comply with the Neutral point of view and No original research requirements imposed by many of the Wikipedia sites.'' Anyway, the hebrew article says that that building was once also mosque, which means that tha clam "misleading name: is not obvious and you have first pass through discussion in the files talk page. [[User:Geagea|Geagea]] ([[User talk:Geagea#top|talk]]) 17:34, 17 March 2013 (UTC)

+
:::::I know that,but COM:NPOV applies to image content, and not that much to the obvious title errors. This building was the church since the creation, than it was transformed into mosque by ottoman turks, but it is church again for almost 100 years. That does not mean that it should be named like that. Identical rule should apply as for the Hagia Sofia in istanbul. It should be named per common name, and not per POV historical titles. Sure, i will not rename it my self, we should agree first. --[[User:WhiteWriter |WhiteWriter ]]^{[[User talk:WhiteWriter |speaks]]}

== {{Autotranslate|base=Idw/heading}} ==

== {{Autotranslate|base=Idw/heading}} ==

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Geagea&diff=92782244&oldid=92767253