22 Mar

User talk:Fastily

‎File:Flag of the farc-ep.png: r
← Older revision
Revision as of 08:34, 22 March 2013
Line 40:
Line 40:

I have seen that you have deleted the file indicated above from Commons, as it had been here from a very long time previously I would like to be sure that this is indeed a new policy of Commons and not just the personal interpretation of the user filing the deletion request. The interpretation of [[User:Futuretrillionaire]] is that the fact that this logo is ''blocked property'' means that ''The U.S. govt doesn't want us to use it at all'', I would say that this sounds to me as something strongly against the common interpretation of Freedom of Speech which is really inclusive in the US if I'm not wrong. Is this interpretation discussed somewhere in Commons or is it just the personal interpretation of this user ? In my opinion, ''blocked property'' would mean that FARC cannot claim any copyright on the flag in the US, and nothing more. I precise that I'm the same person as [[User:Sylvain2803]] who appears in the earlier discussion about the same file, not to be charged with using ''fake nose''. If your discussion page is not the correct place for raising this issue, would you be so kind as to indicate me where to do this, I'm not so familiar with Commons. --[[User:Awkiku|Awkiku]] ([[User talk:Awkiku|talk]]) 13:05, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

I have seen that you have deleted the file indicated above from Commons, as it had been here from a very long time previously I would like to be sure that this is indeed a new policy of Commons and not just the personal interpretation of the user filing the deletion request. The interpretation of [[User:Futuretrillionaire]] is that the fact that this logo is ''blocked property'' means that ''The U.S. govt doesn't want us to use it at all'', I would say that this sounds to me as something strongly against the common interpretation of Freedom of Speech which is really inclusive in the US if I'm not wrong. Is this interpretation discussed somewhere in Commons or is it just the personal interpretation of this user ? In my opinion, ''blocked property'' would mean that FARC cannot claim any copyright on the flag in the US, and nothing more. I precise that I'm the same person as [[User:Sylvain2803]] who appears in the earlier discussion about the same file, not to be charged with using ''fake nose''. If your discussion page is not the correct place for raising this issue, would you be so kind as to indicate me where to do this, I'm not so familiar with Commons. --[[User:Awkiku|Awkiku]] ([[User talk:Awkiku|talk]]) 13:05, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

+
:I've added a more explicit rationale to the discussion. In short, I deleted the file because, as per the discussion, there was no clear indication/written evidence that the file is available/has been published under a [[COM:CT|commons-compatiable license]]. Of course, if you can provide me with said evidence, I'll restore the file immediately and update the file description page accordingly. -[[User:Fastily|FASTILY]] [[User talk:Fastily|^(TALK)]] 08:34, 22 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Fastily&diff=93074081&oldid=93073917