User talk:Dobie80

‎Reverting your changes: re
← Older revision
Revision as of 06:57, 18 March 2013
Line 35:
Line 35:
 
:On the Model in Gold Shirt one, I accidentally put that reason by mistake and had already hit "Save page" before I realized my mistake. I kind of thought it might cause even more confusion if I did a correction correcting my accidental incorrect reasoning. Regarding the gold shirt model's name, it listed her name on the Flickr page that you put as the source for the picture. And the other picture of yours that I corrected with that same name had her name listed on a different picture in her set on that photographer's Flickr page you used as a source. Same for the auburn haired girl. Do the models have to give separate permissions to have their names used on Flickr and to have it used on Wikipedia? If so, I shall stop with the names. Also, do we need to mention where we got their names from so that people can verify it? The reason I like to put their names on it is so that if someone else uploads more pictures of the person, they can easily be put in a gallery together for that person.

 
:On the Model in Gold Shirt one, I accidentally put that reason by mistake and had already hit "Save page" before I realized my mistake. I kind of thought it might cause even more confusion if I did a correction correcting my accidental incorrect reasoning. Regarding the gold shirt model's name, it listed her name on the Flickr page that you put as the source for the picture. And the other picture of yours that I corrected with that same name had her name listed on a different picture in her set on that photographer's Flickr page you used as a source. Same for the auburn haired girl. Do the models have to give separate permissions to have their names used on Flickr and to have it used on Wikipedia? If so, I shall stop with the names. Also, do we need to mention where we got their names from so that people can verify it? The reason I like to put their names on it is so that if someone else uploads more pictures of the person, they can easily be put in a gallery together for that person.

 
:I apologize for any inconvenience. Thank you.--[[User:Dobie80|Dobie80]] ([[User talk:Dobie80#top|talk]]) 06:07, 18 March 2013 (UTC)
 
:I apologize for any inconvenience. Thank you.--[[User:Dobie80|Dobie80]] ([[User talk:Dobie80#top|talk]]) 06:07, 18 March 2013 (UTC)
 
+

 
+
::It's definitely ok to make a minor edit (add a space or something) and in the edit summary state that the ''last'' edit summary was incorrect. That would have certainly cleared up confusion on my part (I wasn't sure if you were the actual photographer or what—I've never seen someone adding names before). That's a relief though, and I apologize for coming across a bit strongly; I thought perhaps your edits were joke edits.
 
+

 
+
::I don't deal with models often; if I notice an article on Wikipedia is missing a picture, or a better picture, I'll hunt one down. If the model has only a first name, to me it's irrelevant for the image description page and the source link will forward anyone to the original image and the name can be found there. Single names are meaningless anyway, until they become notable mononyms (e.g., Madonna). If I found a full name, I would research its notability before including it. If the model has his/her own website and is trying to get their name out there, then I would consider the name fair-use. If the name doesn't link to anything, I consider it private information, even if it's listed on, say, the Flickr page. – Kerαunoςcopia^◁[[:en:User:Keraunoscopia|gala]][[:User talk:Keraunoscopia|xies]] 06:57, 18 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Dobie80&diff=92799808&oldid=92798674