Talk:BSicon/Renaming

‎Roads: moved
← Older revision
Revision as of 20:35, 15 March 2013
Line 733:
Line 733:
 
== Roads ==
 
== Roads ==
 

 

−
If no one objects, I am going to rename the red/yellow and blue highways into {{User|Tuvalkin}}'s "R" set:
+
:''moved to [[Category talk:Icons for railway descriptions/crossing road#Renaming]]''
−

 
−
{|
 
−
|-align=center
 
−
|width=30|RD1
 
−
|width=30|RP1
 
−
|width=30|RP2
 
−
|width=30|RP4
 
−
|width=30|RPA
 
−
|width=30|RPM
 
−
|-align=center
 
−
|{{bsq|RD1|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|RP1|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|RP2|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|RP4|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|MWSTR|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|ROAD|2=0}}
 
−
|-valign=top
 
−
|colspan=4|
 
−
|= '''R'''oad
'''P'''aved
'''A'''utobahn/
'''A'''utoroute/
'''A'''utostrada
 
−
|= '''R'''oad
'''P'''aved
'''M'''otorway
 
−
|} [[User:Useddenim|Useddenim]] ([[User talk:Useddenim|talk]]) 00:19, 24 October 2012 (UTC)
 
−

 
−
:I’m very touched. *.*
 
−
:Seriously, all standardization is good — but maybe before you go ahead and rename, maybe the RPA family should be checked for what’s exRPA and what not? Because I’m not sure that the difference between, say, {{BS-q|MWSTRq}} and {{BS-q|MROADq}} is intentional… -- [[User:Tuvalkin|Tuválkin]] [[User talk:Tuvalkin|✉]] 12:59, 24 October 2012 (UTC)
 
−

 
−
::Since there's only eight unique (12 total) red icons, I'd just convert them all to pink.
See [[User:Circeus/BSicon renaming/Red]] and [[User:Circeus/BSicon renaming/Blue]] for the full catalogue. [[User:Useddenim|Useddenim]] ([[User talk:Useddenim|talk]]) 17:06, 24 October 2012 (UTC)
 
−

 
−
:::Oops—I forgot about all of the AKRZ icons. I think they tilt the count in favour of red instead of pink. [[User:Useddenim|Useddenim]] ([[User talk:Useddenim|talk]]) 03:32, 25 October 2012 (UTC)
 
−

 
−
Question: I was under the impression that the plan was to ultimately use the G-roots (GU, G1-G4) for the RD and RP1-4 names? Tuvalkin was already using these for the new SKRZ icons (which are the expanded form for AKRZ: {{bsq|AKRZu}} -> {{bsq|SKRZ-G1u}}). I never got as far as to figure out a good naming scheme for the more complex icons, but I don't think it's be too hard (a great many can be dealt with by expanding the -Gx suffix to all railway roots: {{bsq|RP2xRP2}} -> KRZ-G2; {{bsq|RP4wns}} -> ABZ-G4l+fg).
 
−

 
−
There are in fact several more different road crossing icons in use that belong in this series: [[User:Circeus/BSicon_renaming/Non-rail_crossings]]. This is why I came up with the SKRZ-xxx scheme.
 
−

 
−
[[User:Circeus|Circeus]] ([[User talk:Circeus|talk]]) 22:20, 25 October 2012 (UTC)
 
−

 
−
:So, then:
 
−
:{|
 
−
|-align=center
 
−
|width=30|-GU
 
−
|width=30|-G1
 
−
|width=30|-G2
 
−
|width=30|-G4
 
−
|width=75|-GA
 
−
|width=75|-GM
 
−
|width=75|-GN
 
−
|width=75|-UA
 
−
|width=75|-UB
 
−
|-align=center
 
−
|{{bsq|RD1|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|RP1|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|RP2|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|RP4|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|MWSTR|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|ROAD|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|uHKRZun|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|uHAROADu|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|KRZquy|2=0}}
 
−
|-valign=top
 
−
|colspan=4|
 
−
|= '''G'''eneric
'''A'''utobahn/
'''A'''utoroute/
'''A'''utostrada
 
−
|= '''G'''eneric
'''M'''otorway
 
−
|= '''G'''eneric
u'''N'''specified
 
−
|align=center|= '''U'''K
'''A''' road
 
−
|align=center|= '''U'''K
'''B''' road
 
−
|} [[User:Useddenim|Useddenim]] ([[User talk:Useddenim|talk]]) 23:28, 25 October 2012 (UTC)
 
−

 
−
::I’m all for consistency and standardization in naming, but the set {{BS-q|RD1|2=0}}{{BS-q|RP1|2=0}}{{BS-q|RP2|2=0}}{{BS-q|RP4|2=0}} is meant to be self-sufficient in describing roads. Therefore the blue and the pink sets should keep names that do not bundle them at the same level as those 4 “generic” profiles. Pls read the intro of [[:Category:Icons for motorway descriptions/generic]] — it is meant to show only how a road more-or-less looks like (number of lines and type of paving), not its classification and tolling regime. Even if the pink and the blue sets cannot be readily pinned to a given country roadmap tradition, use an "X" or any other letter, and leave the "G" for those four.
 
−
::As for renaming things like {{bsq|RP2xRP2}} to '''KRZ-G2''', I’m not frontally against, but the relative merits of that should be discussed in [[Category talk:Icons for motorway descriptions/generic]]. (''I.e.'', whenever there's a rail stretch in one of these road icons, rail nomenclature prevails, when not, lets go easy on the renamings.)
 
−
::-- [[User:Tuvalkin|Tuválkin]] [[User talk:Tuvalkin|✉]] 02:31, 26 October 2012 (UTC)
 
−

 
−
:::I just wanted something simple and consistent... [[User:Useddenim|Useddenim]] ([[User talk:Useddenim|talk]]) 03:37, 26 October 2012 (UTC)
 
−
::Wih non-generic road, I was using a letter followed by the country code for the primary users of that icon:
 
−
::{|
 
−
|-align=center
 
−
|{{bsq|AKRZ-AUKu|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|MWSTR|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|ROAD|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|uHAROADu|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|KRZquy|2=0}}
 
−
|{{bsq|uHKRZun|2=0}}
 
−
|-
 
−
! colspan=6| Proposal 1
 
−
|-align=center
 
−
|width=75|-GG
 
−
|width=75|-ADE
 
−
|width=75|-MUK
 
−
|width=75|-AUK
 
−
|width=75|-BUK
 
−
|width=75|-FNO
 
−
|- valign=top align=center
 
−
|= '''G'''eneric, '''G'''reen
 
−
|= '''A'''utoXXXX/
'''A'''-Road, German
 
−
|= '''M'''otorway, UK
 
−
|= '''A'''utoXXXX/
'''A'''-Road, UK
 
−
|= '''B''' road, '''UK'''
 
−
|= '''F'''ylkesvei, '''No'''rway
 
−
|-
 
−
! colspan=6| Proposal 2
 
−
|-align=center
 
−
|width=75|-GG
 
−
|width=75|-1DE
 
−
|width=75|-1UK
 
−
|width=75|-2UK
 
−
|width=75|-3UK
 
−
|width=75|-3NO
 
−
|- valign=top align=center
 
−
|= '''G'''eneric, '''G'''reen
 
−
|= lvl '''1''' roads, Germany
 
−
|= lvl '''1''' roads, UK
 
−
|= lvl '''2''' roads, UK
 
−
|= lvl '''3''', UK
 
−
|= lvl '''3''', Norway
 
−
|}
 
−
::I'm not clear what the Green icons were supposed to represent, but they are currently used in various ways on several projects. The odd -n icon is overwhelmingly used by the scandinavian projects. This schemes gives a ready, relatively easy way to set up eventual other systems (i.e. -AUS and -MUS would easily fit US roads and interstates respectively). If one wanted to make it even MORE general, you could define Highways as lvl 1 in a descending hierarchy that each country adapts by substituting or adding a lower level to. The only problem with that is that it leads to conflict in what the number means for generic and national icons. [[User:Circeus|Circeus]] ([[User talk:Circeus|talk]]) 16:30, 26 October 2012 (UTC)
 
 

 

 
== More ''Grenzen'' ==
 
== More ''Grenzen'' ==

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:BSicon/Renaming&diff=92641841&oldid=92641053