21 Mar

File talk:HagoshrimHotel.JPG

← Older revision
Revision as of 21:56, 21 March 2013
Line 1:
Line 1:

[[user: TheRealHuldra]] added [[:Category:Al-Khisas]] to the pic. Even though these buildings were built on the grounds of what used to be once Al-Khisas, they are modern buildings and have nothing to do with that village. This category is simply ireelevant. Nobody would add [[:Category: Ancient Rome]] to [[:File:Monumento Vittorio Emanuele II Rom.jpg|this file]], for example, because even though this building was built in what used to be ancient Rome, it has nothing to do with it. [[user: TheRealHuldra]] also claimed that "This is the house of the former sheik of al-Khisa". This is just wrong. The main building of the hotel was indeed the sheikh's house. The buildings in this photo were all built after the sheikh left. [[User:Idobi|Idobi]] ([[User talk:Idobi|talk]]) 08:12, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

[[user: TheRealHuldra]] added [[:Category:Al-Khisas]] to the pic. Even though these buildings were built on the grounds of what used to be once Al-Khisas, they are modern buildings and have nothing to do with that village. This category is simply ireelevant. Nobody would add [[:Category: Ancient Rome]] to [[:File:Monumento Vittorio Emanuele II Rom.jpg|this file]], for example, because even though this building was built in what used to be ancient Rome, it has nothing to do with it. [[user: TheRealHuldra]] also claimed that "This is the house of the former sheik of al-Khisa". This is just wrong. The main building of the hotel was indeed the sheikh's house. The buildings in this photo were all built after the sheikh left. [[User:Idobi|Idobi]] ([[User talk:Idobi|talk]]) 08:12, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

+
:Ok, I was basing my edits on the info I got from Benvenisti: ''Sacred Landscape,'' p. 206-207. I´m not sure what you are basing your info on, [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:OR WP:OR]? Cheers, [[User:TheRealHuldra|TheRealHuldra]] ([[User talk:TheRealHuldra|talk]]) 21:56, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File_talk:HagoshrimHotel.JPG&diff=93047603&oldid=92998518