22 Mar

File talk:HagoshrimHotel.JPG

← Older revision
Revision as of 05:05, 22 March 2013
Line 1:
Line 1:

[[user: TheRealHuldra]] added [[:Category:Al-Khisas]] to the pic. Even though these buildings were built on the grounds of what used to be once Al-Khisas, they are modern buildings and have nothing to do with that village. This category is simply ireelevant. Nobody would add [[:Category: Ancient Rome]] to [[:File:Monumento Vittorio Emanuele II Rom.jpg|this file]], for example, because even though this building was built in what used to be ancient Rome, it has nothing to do with it. [[user: TheRealHuldra]] also claimed that "This is the house of the former sheik of al-Khisa". This is just wrong. The main building of the hotel was indeed the sheikh's house. The buildings in this photo were all built after the sheikh left. [[User:Idobi|Idobi]] ([[User talk:Idobi|talk]]) 08:12, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

[[user: TheRealHuldra]] added [[:Category:Al-Khisas]] to the pic. Even though these buildings were built on the grounds of what used to be once Al-Khisas, they are modern buildings and have nothing to do with that village. This category is simply ireelevant. Nobody would add [[:Category: Ancient Rome]] to [[:File:Monumento Vittorio Emanuele II Rom.jpg|this file]], for example, because even though this building was built in what used to be ancient Rome, it has nothing to do with it. [[user: TheRealHuldra]] also claimed that "This is the house of the former sheik of al-Khisa". This is just wrong. The main building of the hotel was indeed the sheikh's house. The buildings in this photo were all built after the sheikh left. [[User:Idobi|Idobi]] ([[User talk:Idobi|talk]]) 08:12, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

:Ok, I was basing my edits on the info I got from Benvenisti: ''Sacred Landscape,'' p. 206-207. I´m not sure what you are basing your info on, [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:OR WP:OR]? Cheers, [[User:TheRealHuldra|TheRealHuldra]] ([[User talk:TheRealHuldra|talk]]) 21:56, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

:Ok, I was basing my edits on the info I got from Benvenisti: ''Sacred Landscape,'' p. 206-207. I´m not sure what you are basing your info on, [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:OR WP:OR]? Cheers, [[User:TheRealHuldra|TheRealHuldra]] ([[User talk:TheRealHuldra|talk]]) 21:56, 21 March 2013 (UTC)
−
::As I was saying, the main stone building of the hotel, which you can see [[:PikiWiki Israel 15319 Hotel Kibbutz Hagoshrim.JPG|here]] or [[:Hagoshrim hotel in Kibbutz Hagoshrim.JPG|here]] WAS the sheikh's house. I suppose that this is what Benvenisti says. Does he say that the small concrete houses that are scattered next to it and look like the rest of the kibbutz's houses were also part of the sheikh's house? I find it hard to believe. Please check yourself. [[User:Idobi|Idobi]] ([[User talk:Idobi|talk]]) 05:05, 22 March 2013 (UTC)
+
::As I was saying, the main stone building of the hotel, which you can see [[:Gile:PikiWiki Israel 15319 Hotel Kibbutz Hagoshrim.JPG|here]] or [[:File:Hagoshrim hotel in Kibbutz Hagoshrim.JPG|here]] WAS the sheikh's house. I suppose that this is what Benvenisti says. Does he say that the small concrete houses that are scattered next to it and look like the rest of the kibbutz's houses were also part of the sheikh's house? I find it hard to believe. Please check yourself. [[User:Idobi|Idobi]] ([[User talk:Idobi|talk]]) 05:05, 22 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=File_talk:HagoshrimHotel.JPG&diff=93067782&oldid=93067765