28 Mar

Commons:Village pump

‎Assistance with No Source tag on File:Scallop Diagram.jpg: Used other's work as guides but nothing was copied.
← Older revision
Revision as of 01:55, 28 March 2013
Line 792:
Line 792:

Am hoping for a little guidance here. A couple of days ago I uploaded an image I created and titled '''Scallop Diagram.jpg'''. Not long after, another editor tagged it with the {{no source since}} tag, even though I had marked |source={{own}}} in the image's information template. Two things: the other editor ([[User:Moros y Christianos]]) was certainly correct to doubt the image as having been created by me, as it is really a very nice picture-- I want to be clear that I am flattered to have my work doubted. Having said this, I am hesitant to remove the no-source-since tag myself as this seems obviously inappropriate. I have tried to contact the other editor through his/ her talk page, but so far have gotten no response. What is the policy/ procedure when someone uploads an image and another editor responds with, "That can't really be YOURS"? How do I handle this? Please advise. Thank you! [[User:KDS444|KDS444]] ([[User talk:KDS444|talk]]) 06:51, 27 March 2013 (UTC)

Am hoping for a little guidance here. A couple of days ago I uploaded an image I created and titled '''Scallop Diagram.jpg'''. Not long after, another editor tagged it with the {{no source since}} tag, even though I had marked |source={{own}}} in the image's information template. Two things: the other editor ([[User:Moros y Christianos]]) was certainly correct to doubt the image as having been created by me, as it is really a very nice picture-- I want to be clear that I am flattered to have my work doubted. Having said this, I am hesitant to remove the no-source-since tag myself as this seems obviously inappropriate. I have tried to contact the other editor through his/ her talk page, but so far have gotten no response. What is the policy/ procedure when someone uploads an image and another editor responds with, "That can't really be YOURS"? How do I handle this? Please advise. Thank you! [[User:KDS444|KDS444]] ([[User talk:KDS444|talk]]) 06:51, 27 March 2013 (UTC)

:Just curious, is the diagram based off of any existing diagram? Or did you use a pre-existing diagram/template image which you then modified to create the final product? -[[User:Fastily|FASTILY]] [[User talk:Fastily|^(TALK)]] 07:29, 27 March 2013 (UTC)

:Just curious, is the diagram based off of any existing diagram? Or did you use a pre-existing diagram/template image which you then modified to create the final product? -[[User:Fastily|FASTILY]] [[User talk:Fastily|^(TALK)]] 07:29, 27 March 2013 (UTC)

+
::I studied a set of 5 or 6 different photographs and drawings before beginning my own. I did not use any parts of those photos or drawings in generating this image-- I occasionally referred them to make sure I was putting the correct organ in the correct place, but nothing more than this.[[User:KDS444|KDS444]] ([[User talk:KDS444|talk]]) 01:55, 28 March 2013 (UTC)

== Smaller dr notifications ==

== Smaller dr notifications ==

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Village_pump&diff=93421500&oldid=93418860