Commons:Valued image candidates/Messinian salinity crisis

VIS promotion
← Older revision
Revision as of 03:53, 17 March 2013
Line 11:
Line 11:
 
|nominator=[[User:Dvdgmz|Dvdgmz]] ([[User talk:Dvdgmz|talk]])
 
|nominator=[[User:Dvdgmz|Dvdgmz]] ([[User talk:Dvdgmz|talk]])
 
|scope=The [[:Category:Messinian salinity crisis|Messinian salinity crisis]] in the Mediterranean sea
 
|scope=The [[:Category:Messinian salinity crisis|Messinian salinity crisis]] in the Mediterranean sea
 
+
|titlescope=Messinian salinity crisis in the Mediterranean sea
 
+
|parent=
 
+
[[:Category:Messinian salinity crisis|Messinian salinity crisis]]
 
|orientation=landscape
 
|orientation=landscape
 
|usedin=[[w:en:Mediterranean Sea]], [[w:en:Messinian salinity crisis]], [[w:en:Zanclean flood]], [[w:es:Crisis salina del Messiniense]],
 
|usedin=[[w:en:Mediterranean Sea]], [[w:en:Messinian salinity crisis]], [[w:en:Zanclean flood]], [[w:es:Crisis salina del Messiniense]],
−
|status=supported
+
|status=promoted
 
|review= *{{support}} As a geophysicist academician and frequent editor on earth science, i agree that this set is representative for the current consensus among geoscientists on the subject. [[User:Gaianauta|Gaianauta]] ([[User talk:Gaianauta|talk]]) 21:48, 4 March 2013 (UTC)
 
|review= *{{support}} As a geophysicist academician and frequent editor on earth science, i agree that this set is representative for the current consensus among geoscientists on the subject. [[User:Gaianauta|Gaianauta]] ([[User talk:Gaianauta|talk]]) 21:48, 4 March 2013 (UTC)
 
*{{support}}. All criteria are met: '''1. Is the most valuable illustration of its kind on Wikimedia Commons'''. At the moment it's the only illustration providing a '''complete''' description of the Messinian salinization process. '''2. Is nominated as being the most valuable within a suitably generic scope'''. Scope is right. Other broader scopes could be also used (such as Geologic history of the Mediterranean Sea or Salinization processes). '''3. Must illustrate its subject well'''. It clearly describes the whole process illustrating entirely the subject. As the wikiArS initiative relies on the cooperation of experts in their field, we can trust it scientific accuracy. '''4. Is fully described on the image page'''. Fully compliant. '''5. Is geocoded, when relevant'''. It does not apply (valid exceptions are maps). '''6. Is well categorized at an appropriate level'''. Specific category exists. --[[User:ecemaml|Ecemaml]] ^{[[User_talk:ecemaml|talk to me/habla conmigo]]} 09:25, 7 March 2013 (UTC)
 
*{{support}}. All criteria are met: '''1. Is the most valuable illustration of its kind on Wikimedia Commons'''. At the moment it's the only illustration providing a '''complete''' description of the Messinian salinization process. '''2. Is nominated as being the most valuable within a suitably generic scope'''. Scope is right. Other broader scopes could be also used (such as Geologic history of the Mediterranean Sea or Salinization processes). '''3. Must illustrate its subject well'''. It clearly describes the whole process illustrating entirely the subject. As the wikiArS initiative relies on the cooperation of experts in their field, we can trust it scientific accuracy. '''4. Is fully described on the image page'''. Fully compliant. '''5. Is geocoded, when relevant'''. It does not apply (valid exceptions are maps). '''6. Is well categorized at an appropriate level'''. Specific category exists. --[[User:ecemaml|Ecemaml]] ^{[[User_talk:ecemaml|talk to me/habla conmigo]]} 09:25, 7 March 2013 (UTC)
 
*I agree with the additional scopes suggested by Ecemaml. The [[Commons:Valued_image_candidates#Changes_in_scope_during_the_review_period|change must be]] applied by the nomitator [[user:dvdgmz]]. - [[User:Gaianauta|Gaianauta]] ([[User talk:Gaianauta|talk]]) 16:08, 10 March 2013 (UTC)
 
*I agree with the additional scopes suggested by Ecemaml. The [[Commons:Valued_image_candidates#Changes_in_scope_during_the_review_period|change must be]] applied by the nomitator [[user:dvdgmz]]. - [[User:Gaianauta|Gaianauta]] ([[User talk:Gaianauta|talk]]) 16:08, 10 March 2013 (UTC)
 
** {{comment}} As the proposal is to add scopes I've added them as categories to the images that match, but I don't change the initial scope that is not questioned.--[[User:Dvdgmz|Dvdgmz]] ([[User talk:Dvdgmz|talk]]) 18:02, 10 March 2013 (UTC)
 
** {{comment}} As the proposal is to add scopes I've added them as categories to the images that match, but I don't change the initial scope that is not questioned.--[[User:Dvdgmz|Dvdgmz]] ([[User talk:Dvdgmz|talk]]) 18:02, 10 March 2013 (UTC)
−
}}
+
{{vicl|2|0|[[User:Godot13|Godot13]] ([[User talk:Godot13|talk]]) 03:53, 17 March 2013 (UTC)}}}}

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Valued_image_candidates/Messinian_salinity_crisis&diff=92730742&oldid=92346566