26 Mar

Commons talk:Deletion requests/File:North-Cape-Globe-2012-07-14-20-50.jpg

post-closure comment
New pagePost-closure comment:
While I agree that deletion is "the right thing to do" based on "when in doubt, play it safe," I disagree with [[User:Stefan4]]'s assumption that the globe was more complex than the chair. The globe was basically a circle of steel for the equator and several equally-spaced circles intersecting at the poles, perched atop a pyramid. Even if this were "more complex" than the particular chair mentioned, it was not more original. In fact, the two constituent parts - the sphere part and the pyramid part - had zero originality in and of themselves. The only original aspects I could see were ''maybe'' the combination of these two simple shapes and ''maybe'' their placement in a particular location where they were installed. I'm making these comments now so they can be part of any future un-deletion decision. [[User:Davidwr|Davidwr]] ([[User talk:Davidwr|talk]]) 19:16, 26 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons_talk:Deletion_requests/File:North-Cape-Globe-2012-07-14-20-50.jpg&diff=93322782&oldid=0