Commons:Graphic Lab/Illustration workshop

‎Can't we have just one correct picture of something? (Coat of arms of Pope Francis)
← Older revision
Revision as of 16:48, 26 March 2013
Line 709:
Line 709:
 

 

 

 

 
+
Signum Francisci.svg|1
 
+
Coat of arms of Franciscus.svg|2
 
+
Pope Francis CoA.svg|3
 
+
Blason fictif du Pape François.svg|4
 
+
COA Franciscus.svg|5
 
+
Fictional Coat of arms of Pope Francis.svg|6
 

 

 

 

 
'''Request:''' I wonder if we can have only one correct representative of the coat of arms of Pope Francis. There are now 10 images in [[:Category:Coats of arms of Franciscus|the category]], and now none of them look exactly like the one in [http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/francesco/elezione/stemma-papa-francesco_it.html the official Vatican page]. Previously, there were 3 files ([[:File:Signum Francisci.svg|this]], [[:File:Coat of arms of Franciscus.svg|this]], and [[:File:Pope Francis CoA.svg|this]]) which looked very similar to [http://attualita.vatican.va/sala-stampa/bollettino/2013/03/18/news/30649.html the first released] coat of arms, and all the file creators seemed to want their pictures present in Commons and try to change the pictures to be very similar to one another. I mean, why can't we have just one file for this? [[User:Sentausa|Sentausa]] ([[User talk:Sentausa|talk]]) 16:04, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
 
'''Request:''' I wonder if we can have only one correct representative of the coat of arms of Pope Francis. There are now 10 images in [[:Category:Coats of arms of Franciscus|the category]], and now none of them look exactly like the one in [http://www.vatican.va/holy_father/francesco/elezione/stemma-papa-francesco_it.html the official Vatican page]. Previously, there were 3 files ([[:File:Signum Francisci.svg|this]], [[:File:Coat of arms of Franciscus.svg|this]], and [[:File:Pope Francis CoA.svg|this]]) which looked very similar to [http://attualita.vatican.va/sala-stampa/bollettino/2013/03/18/news/30649.html the first released] coat of arms, and all the file creators seemed to want their pictures present in Commons and try to change the pictures to be very similar to one another. I mean, why can't we have just one file for this? [[User:Sentausa|Sentausa]] ([[User talk:Sentausa|talk]]) 16:04, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
 

 

−

+
'''Graphist opinion(s):''' Well, for me, the PNGs and JPEG should go as they're of equal quality to the SVGs at best. [[:File:Fictional_depiction_of_a_coat_of_arms_for_Pope_Francis.svg|This one]] is gorgeous and I would say it should be kept for artistic merit if nothing else. Numbers 4, 5 and 6 above all use the wrong style of keys; the others are all essentially identical, so I would say we should either delete all but the first uploaded, or instead keep the one with the most appropriate name. Then we can touch it up to match the Vatican's version as closely as we desire. I do predict edit warring, whatever happens! [[User:NikNaks|NikNaks]] _{[[User talk:NikNaks|talk]] - [[User:NikNaks/Gallery|gallery]] - [[w:User:NikNaks|wikipedia]]} 16:48, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
−
'''Graphist opinion(s):'''
 
 

\n \u00a0

\n\u00a0

\n \u00a0

\n\u00a0
\n +
\n Signum Francisci.svg|1
\n\u00a0
\n +
\n Coat of arms of Franciscus.svg|2
\n\u00a0
\n +
\n Pope Francis CoA.svg|3
\n\u00a0
\n +
\n Blason fictif du Pape Fran\u00e7ois.svg|4
\n\u00a0
\n +
\n COA Franciscus.svg|5
\n\u00a0
\n +
\n Fictional Coat of arms of Pope Francis.svg|6
\n\u00a0
<\/gallery>
\n \u00a0
<\/gallery>
\n\u00a0

\n \u00a0

\n\u00a0
\n '''Request:''' I wonder if we can have only one correct representative of the coat of arms of Pope Francis. There are now 10 images in [[:Category:Coats of arms of Franciscus|the category]], and now none of them look exactly like the one in [http:\/\/www.vatican.va\/holy_father\/francesco\/elezione\/stemma-papa-francesco_it.html the official Vatican page]. Previously, there were 3 files ([[:File:Signum Francisci.svg|this]], [[:File:Coat of arms of Franciscus.svg|this]], and [[:File:Pope Francis CoA.svg|this]]) which looked very similar to [http:\/\/attualita.vatican.va\/sala-stampa\/bollettino\/2013\/03\/18\/news\/30649.html the first released] coat of arms, and all the file creators seemed to want their pictures present in Commons and try to change the pictures to be very similar to one another. I mean, why can't we have just one file for this? [[User:Sentausa|Sentausa]] ([[User talk:Sentausa|talk<\/span>]]) 16:04, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
\n \u00a0
\n '''Request:''' I wonder if we can have only one correct representative of the coat of arms of Pope Francis. There are now 10 images in [[:Category:Coats of arms of Franciscus|the category]], and now none of them look exactly like the one in [http:\/\/www.vatican.va\/holy_father\/francesco\/elezione\/stemma-papa-francesco_it.html the official Vatican page]. Previously, there were 3 files ([[:File:Signum Francisci.svg|this]], [[:File:Coat of arms of Franciscus.svg|this]], and [[:File:Pope Francis CoA.svg|this]]) which looked very similar to [http:\/\/attualita.vatican.va\/sala-stampa\/bollettino\/2013\/03\/18\/news\/30649.html the first released] coat of arms, and all the file creators seemed to want their pictures present in Commons and try to change the pictures to be very similar to one another. I mean, why can't we have just one file for this? [[User:Sentausa|Sentausa]] ([[User talk:Sentausa|talk<\/span>]]) 16:04, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
\n\u00a0

\n \u00a0

\n\u2212

\n +
\n '''Graphist opinion(s):''' Well, for me, the PNGs and JPEG should go as they're of equal quality to the SVGs at best. [[:File:Fictional_depiction_of_a_coat_of_arms_for_Pope_Francis.svg|This one]] is gorgeous and I would say it should be kept for artistic merit if nothing else. Numbers 4, 5 and 6 above all use the wrong style of keys; the others are all essentially identical, so I would say we should either delete all but the first uploaded, or instead keep the one with the most appropriate name. Then we can touch it up to match the Vatican's version as closely as we desire. I do predict edit warring, whatever happens! [[User:NikNaks|Nik<\/font>Naks<\/font><\/b>]] _{[[User talk:NikNaks|talk]] - [[User:NikNaks\/Gallery|gallery]] - [[w:User:NikNaks|wikipedia]]<\/sub> 16:48, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
\n\u2212
\n '''Graphist opinion(s):'''
\n \u00a0
\n\u00a0}