Commons:Deletion requests/File:SCOPELLO copia.jpg

Kept:
← Older revision
Revision as of 01:34, 1 April 2013
Line 1:
Line 1:
−

+
{{delh}}
 
=== [[:File:SCOPELLO copia.jpg]] ===
 
=== [[:File:SCOPELLO copia.jpg]] ===
 
doubtful source, possible copyvio; file lacks basic information [[User:Coronades03|G. Coronades]] | [[User_talk:Coronades03|Do you have a question?]] 22:46, 28 January 2013 (UTC)
 
doubtful source, possible copyvio; file lacks basic information [[User:Coronades03|G. Coronades]] | [[User_talk:Coronades03|Do you have a question?]] 22:46, 28 January 2013 (UTC)
 
:{{Keep}}. That's an upload from 2006, nearly 7 years ago. Back then uploading was extremely basic and most users considered a CC-by licence declaring 'I, the copyright owner' as enough to express that an image is own source. Looking at the contributions of the uploader they are pretty much all the same style (colouring, style, ...) from the same source and they all were either typical vacation pictures or pictures from Italy (which I think is the home of the uploader). In his deleted contributions about a third of the images were deleted because of renaming (which back than also worked a lot different than nowadays). Of the rest they were either victims of the strict Italian FOP-law (which normal uploaders are seldomly aware of) or they were drawings of starting positions of soccer games which had a different description/licence indicating that he was transferring them from somewhere and thus they really lacked the source. Of all the deleted uploads I see exactly one real copyvio upload. So no I don't think this is a possible copyvio and I can't see any reason to doubt the source.
 
:{{Keep}}. That's an upload from 2006, nearly 7 years ago. Back then uploading was extremely basic and most users considered a CC-by licence declaring 'I, the copyright owner' as enough to express that an image is own source. Looking at the contributions of the uploader they are pretty much all the same style (colouring, style, ...) from the same source and they all were either typical vacation pictures or pictures from Italy (which I think is the home of the uploader). In his deleted contributions about a third of the images were deleted because of renaming (which back than also worked a lot different than nowadays). Of the rest they were either victims of the strict Italian FOP-law (which normal uploaders are seldomly aware of) or they were drawings of starting positions of soccer games which had a different description/licence indicating that he was transferring them from somewhere and thus they really lacked the source. Of all the deleted uploads I see exactly one real copyvio upload. So no I don't think this is a possible copyvio and I can't see any reason to doubt the source.
 
:And thanks for creating an own deletion request for each of the many images of the uploader instead of putting them all together. I think over the time our script creators made work a little bit too easy and this case is how to misuse that. Especially since most of them had thanks to removing the border bots and other users as recipients of the notification. -- [[User:Cecil|Cecil]] ([[User talk:Cecil|talk]]) 03:38, 29 January 2013 (UTC)
 
:And thanks for creating an own deletion request for each of the many images of the uploader instead of putting them all together. I think over the time our script creators made work a little bit too easy and this case is how to misuse that. Especially since most of them had thanks to removing the border bots and other users as recipients of the notification. -- [[User:Cecil|Cecil]] ([[User talk:Cecil|talk]]) 03:38, 29 January 2013 (UTC)
 
+
----
 
+
'''Kept:''' [[User:Fastily|FASTILY]] [[User talk:Fastily|^(TALK)]] 01:34, 1 April 2013 (UTC)
 
+
{{delf}}

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Deletion_requests/File:SCOPELLO_copia.jpg&diff=93715434&oldid=89163062