26 Mar

Commons:Deletion requests/File:Panzer-Kaserne Böblingen 1958.jpg

‎File:Panzer-Kaserne Böblingen 1958.jpg
← Older revision
Revision as of 11:35, 26 March 2013
Line 13:
Line 13:

:For this photo to be PD, said soldier needs to make it ''for the Army'' in some way, be it as a member of the Signal Corps, for a brochure, military newspaper, whatever. If the hypothetical truck driver you mention photographed this for himself in his spare time, it's not a PD-USGov photo, but a private photo. You cannot assume something like "He was in service for four years and every photograph he made during these four years is automatically PD-USGov". That is ''not'' the case. --[[User:Rosenzweig|Rosenzweig]] [[User talk:Rosenzweig|'''''τ''''']] 18:00, 25 March 2013 (UTC)

:For this photo to be PD, said soldier needs to make it ''for the Army'' in some way, be it as a member of the Signal Corps, for a brochure, military newspaper, whatever. If the hypothetical truck driver you mention photographed this for himself in his spare time, it's not a PD-USGov photo, but a private photo. You cannot assume something like "He was in service for four years and every photograph he made during these four years is automatically PD-USGov". That is ''not'' the case. --[[User:Rosenzweig|Rosenzweig]] [[User talk:Rosenzweig|'''''τ''''']] 18:00, 25 March 2013 (UTC)

+

+
:Thats' simply a speculation by yourself and not real - PDUS Gov says "Dieses Bild wurde von einem Mitglied der United States Army während der Ausführung seiner Dienstpflichten erstellt." nothing else - not “for” the Army but “during he's in service for the army”. No word of an official photo order or if a private snapshoot. He just must be a member of the US Governement that's all. Und jetzt gib endlich mal Ruhe Du gehst mir auf den Sack mit deiner an den Haaren herangezogenen Besserwisserei. - Ende Gelände -- [[User:Steinbeisser|Steinbeisser]] ([[User talk:Steinbeisser|talk]]) 11:35, 26 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Deletion_requests/File:Panzer-Kaserne_B%C3%B6blingen_1958.jpg&diff=93301137&oldid=93264666