25 Mar

Commons:Deletion requests/File:Panzer-Kaserne Böblingen 1958.jpg

no
← Older revision
Revision as of 18:00, 25 March 2013
Line 11:
Line 11:

PF-US-Gov says: "Dieses Bild wurde von einem Mitglied der United States Army während der Ausführung seiner Dienstpflichten erstellt." What does that means? The photographer must be a member of the US Army and in service when he made the photo and not that he had an order to make it or he had to be an officially photographer for a brochure or a military newspaper! What, if the photographer made the photo when he was on pause during his normal military work - maybe as a truck driver of one of the trucks as seen? So he was on duty “während der Ausführung seiner Dienstpflichten” So it's no need for an officially term and the photo is legal for commons! . That's all and very simply ! -- [[User:Steinbeisser|Steinbeisser]] ([[User talk:Steinbeisser|talk]]) 07:37, 25 March 2013 (UTC)

PF-US-Gov says: "Dieses Bild wurde von einem Mitglied der United States Army während der Ausführung seiner Dienstpflichten erstellt." What does that means? The photographer must be a member of the US Army and in service when he made the photo and not that he had an order to make it or he had to be an officially photographer for a brochure or a military newspaper! What, if the photographer made the photo when he was on pause during his normal military work - maybe as a truck driver of one of the trucks as seen? So he was on duty “während der Ausführung seiner Dienstpflichten” So it's no need for an officially term and the photo is legal for commons! . That's all and very simply ! -- [[User:Steinbeisser|Steinbeisser]] ([[User talk:Steinbeisser|talk]]) 07:37, 25 March 2013 (UTC)

+

+
:For this photo to be PD, said soldier needs to make it ''for the Army'' in some way, be it as a member of the Signal Corps, for a brochure, military newspaper, whatever. If the hypothetical truck driver you mention photographed this for himself in his spare time, it's not a PD-USGov photo, but a private photo. You cannot assume something like "He was in service for four years and every photograph he made during these four years is automatically PD-USGov". That is ''not'' the case. --[[User:Rosenzweig|Rosenzweig]] [[User talk:Rosenzweig|'''''τ''''']] 18:00, 25 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Deletion_requests/File:Panzer-Kaserne_B%C3%B6blingen_1958.jpg&diff=93264666&oldid=93236503