21 Mar

Commons:Deletion requests/File:Anna-Victoria-Wood-95.png

‎File:Anna-Victoria-Wood-95.png: moving file back to enWP
← Older revision
Revision as of 23:06, 21 March 2013
Line 9:
Line 9:

:::Following up on the question of whether the initial OTRS permissions was fraudulent, I'll note that many people are under the impression that if they take a picture of something, they own the copyright to it. They are not wrong. However, they are unaware of the concept of derivative rights so they are unaware that they also need the permission of the item being photographed, in some cases. I still don't know all the facts, but I would avoid the term "fradudulent" without knowing all the fact, It may turn out to be simple ignorance of copyright law. In view of the history, that may be less likely, but I don't believe we need to answer the question to determine whether the image should be deleted. If the person cannot provide proof that the underlying photo is free, it must be deleted. If the underlying photo is free, then we have other questions to answer, but I doubt we will get that far.--[[User:Sphilbrick|Sphilbrick]] ([[User talk:Sphilbrick|talk]]) 00:00, 16 March 2013 (UTC)

:::Following up on the question of whether the initial OTRS permissions was fraudulent, I'll note that many people are under the impression that if they take a picture of something, they own the copyright to it. They are not wrong. However, they are unaware of the concept of derivative rights so they are unaware that they also need the permission of the item being photographed, in some cases. I still don't know all the facts, but I would avoid the term "fradudulent" without knowing all the fact, It may turn out to be simple ignorance of copyright law. In view of the history, that may be less likely, but I don't believe we need to answer the question to determine whether the image should be deleted. If the person cannot provide proof that the underlying photo is free, it must be deleted. If the underlying photo is free, then we have other questions to answer, but I doubt we will get that far.--[[User:Sphilbrick|Sphilbrick]] ([[User talk:Sphilbrick|talk]]) 00:00, 16 March 2013 (UTC)

+
::::As it is a transfer to Commons from enWP, I am transferring the file back to enWP {{tl|fair use delete}} as it could be argued there as a case of fair use. Here there are sufficient doubts about the file and derivative rights to delete the file here. — [[user:billinghurst|billinghurst]] ''[[user talk:billinghurst|sDrewth]]'' 23:06, 21 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Deletion_requests/File:Anna-Victoria-Wood-95.png&diff=93051055&oldid=92649912