15 Mar

Commons:Deletion requests/File:Anna-Victoria-Wood-95.png

recommend deletion
← Older revision
Revision as of 23:53, 15 March 2013
Line 5:
Line 5:

::It's a genuine OTRS ticket referring to the image - otherwise I wouldn't have moved it ;-) - OTRS ticket was added (22:02, 21 July 2012) when the image was on en-wiki by [[:en:User:Sphilbrick]]. See also [[:en:Wikipedia:Possibly_unfree_files/2012_June_29#File:Anna-Victoria-Wood-95.png]] '''[[User:Ronhjones| Ronhjones ]]'''^{[[User talk:Ronhjones| (Talk)]]} 20:00, 14 March 2013 (UTC)

::It's a genuine OTRS ticket referring to the image - otherwise I wouldn't have moved it ;-) - OTRS ticket was added (22:02, 21 July 2012) when the image was on en-wiki by [[:en:User:Sphilbrick]]. See also [[:en:Wikipedia:Possibly_unfree_files/2012_June_29#File:Anna-Victoria-Wood-95.png]] '''[[User:Ronhjones| Ronhjones ]]'''^{[[User talk:Ronhjones| (Talk)]]} 20:00, 14 March 2013 (UTC)

:::The thing is that the uploader has been blocked for uploading lots of copyright violations (check the accounts listed at [[w:Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Ashton 29/Archive]]), so I just want to be extra certain. It says: "Author: School photographer (taken 17 years ago in early 1995). Belongs to her parents." Do we have permission from someone who would likely be the copyright holder to a school photo? Her parents have a photo on the wall (see [http://www.smh.com.au/national/health/no-retreat-in-this-fight-anna-woods-parents-want-zerotolerance-20120520-1yz14.html]), but they are obviously not the copyright holders to a school photo. Also, if the uploader is the photographer as he claimed, then why did he grab a photo of the badge from the Internet? I would assume that the photographer has a badge himself and that it would be easier for him to take his own photo of the badge instead. --[[User:Stefan4|Stefan4]] ([[User talk:Stefan4|talk]]) 20:52, 14 March 2013 (UTC)

:::The thing is that the uploader has been blocked for uploading lots of copyright violations (check the accounts listed at [[w:Wikipedia:Sockpuppet investigations/Ashton 29/Archive]]), so I just want to be extra certain. It says: "Author: School photographer (taken 17 years ago in early 1995). Belongs to her parents." Do we have permission from someone who would likely be the copyright holder to a school photo? Her parents have a photo on the wall (see [http://www.smh.com.au/national/health/no-retreat-in-this-fight-anna-woods-parents-want-zerotolerance-20120520-1yz14.html]), but they are obviously not the copyright holders to a school photo. Also, if the uploader is the photographer as he claimed, then why did he grab a photo of the badge from the Internet? I would assume that the photographer has a badge himself and that it would be easier for him to take his own photo of the badge instead. --[[User:Stefan4|Stefan4]] ([[User talk:Stefan4|talk]]) 20:52, 14 March 2013 (UTC)

+
:::The initial permission was granted with a dose of AGF, but subsequent events have called that into question. It is unclear now whether the uploader took a picture of a button, or found an image of the button online. However, in either case, it is derivative of the underlying photo, and we have no evidence that the original photo is properly licensed. Absent that, I think it should be deleted.--[[User:Sphilbrick|Sphilbrick]] ([[User talk:Sphilbrick|talk]]) 23:53, 15 March 2013 (UTC)

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Deletion_requests/File:Anna-Victoria-Wood-95.png&diff=92649697&oldid=92587575