Commons:Deletion requests/Fictional Papal Arms

‎File:Fictional depiction of a coat of arms for Pope Francis.svg
← Older revision
Revision as of 18:04, 26 March 2013
Line 14:
Line 14:
 
=== [[:File:Fictional depiction of a coat of arms for Pope Francis.svg]] ===
 
=== [[:File:Fictional depiction of a coat of arms for Pope Francis.svg]] ===
 
{{vk}} Dude, we already just went through this less than two days ago at [[Commons:Deletion requests/File:Personal coat of arms of Pope Francis.svg]]. It's a reasonable provisional extrapolation (until the official arms are announced), and it's perfectly fine as long as it's labelled as such. We already have thousands of "Special or fictional flags" and "Special or fictional coats of arms" images here on Commons, and this one is probably more useful than most. Furthermore '''WIKIMEDIA COMMONS DOES NOT HAVE A "NO ORIGINAL RESEARCH POLICY"!!!''' (I really get tired of repeating this), so "original research" has nothing to do with image deletion here... [[User:AnonMoos|AnonMoos]] ([[User talk:AnonMoos|talk]]) 18:24, 16 March 2013 (UTC)
 
{{vk}} Dude, we already just went through this less than two days ago at [[Commons:Deletion requests/File:Personal coat of arms of Pope Francis.svg]]. It's a reasonable provisional extrapolation (until the official arms are announced), and it's perfectly fine as long as it's labelled as such. We already have thousands of "Special or fictional flags" and "Special or fictional coats of arms" images here on Commons, and this one is probably more useful than most. Furthermore '''WIKIMEDIA COMMONS DOES NOT HAVE A "NO ORIGINAL RESEARCH POLICY"!!!''' (I really get tired of repeating this), so "original research" has nothing to do with image deletion here... [[User:AnonMoos|AnonMoos]] ([[User talk:AnonMoos|talk]]) 18:24, 16 March 2013 (UTC)
−
Really, there is an No-OR-policy, as self-created artwork is out of scope.--[[User:Antemister|Antemister]] ([[User talk:Antemister|talk]]) 15:53, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
+

 
:Yeah, and the fact that there's a Tiara on top is totally NPOV, isn't it? --[[Special:Contributions/67.142.173.24|67.142.173.24]] 20:07, 16 March 2013 (UTC)
 
:Yeah, and the fact that there's a Tiara on top is totally NPOV, isn't it? --[[Special:Contributions/67.142.173.24|67.142.173.24]] 20:07, 16 March 2013 (UTC)
 

 

Line 40:
Line 40:
 
--[[User:Dbachmann|Dbachmann]] ([[User talk:Dbachmann|talk]]) 12:06, 20 March 2013 (UTC)
 
--[[User:Dbachmann|Dbachmann]] ([[User talk:Dbachmann|talk]]) 12:06, 20 March 2013 (UTC)
 
:There's [[:File:Signum Francisci.svg]], which follows the official version most closely. There's [[:File:Fictional depiction of a coat of arms for Pope Francis.svg]], which has a variation with a tiara in a different style. And then the rest are a bunch of vector and raster files based on the svg version of the previous Pope's arms, they could be reduced to one single file if needed. The three remaining raster files have a different style, but all lack proper sources and attribution anyway. My assessment would leave us with two or three different files: the official arms, the arms with tiara, and the arms in the style of Benedict XVI (with pallium I guess). [[User:Adelbrecht|Lemmens, Tom]] ([[User talk:Adelbrecht|talk]]) 14:17, 20 March 2013 (UTC)
 
:There's [[:File:Signum Francisci.svg]], which follows the official version most closely. There's [[:File:Fictional depiction of a coat of arms for Pope Francis.svg]], which has a variation with a tiara in a different style. And then the rest are a bunch of vector and raster files based on the svg version of the previous Pope's arms, they could be reduced to one single file if needed. The three remaining raster files have a different style, but all lack proper sources and attribution anyway. My assessment would leave us with two or three different files: the official arms, the arms with tiara, and the arms in the style of Benedict XVI (with pallium I guess). [[User:Adelbrecht|Lemmens, Tom]] ([[User talk:Adelbrecht|talk]]) 14:17, 20 March 2013 (UTC)
 
+

 
+
Really, there is an No-OR-policy, as self-created artwork is out of scope.--[[User:Antemister|Antemister]] ([[User talk:Antemister|talk]]) 15:53, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
 
+

 
+
:First off, you added your comment in completely the wrong place. And (as unfortunately seems to be so often the case with you), you're completely wrong -- "No Original Research" and "not a webhost for personal artistic portfolios" are completely separate things which have absolutely nothing to do with each other. Since Commons doesn't have a "No Original Policy", that means that people are free to conduct original research to come up with within-scope graphics... [[User:AnonMoos|AnonMoos]] ([[User talk:AnonMoos|talk]]) 18:04, 26 March 2013 (UTC)
 

 

 
=== [[:File:Herb papieża Franciszka I.png]] ===
 
=== [[:File:Herb papieża Franciszka I.png]] ===

http://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?title=Commons:Deletion_requests/Fictional_Papal_Arms&diff=93318611&oldid=93311283